21-11-2026 12:00:00 AM
A division bench of the Telangana High Court upheld the order of a single judge that set aside the compulsory retirement of an employee of a Central Government institute, holding that the power under Fundamental Rule 56(j) could not be used as a device to cut short pending disciplinary proceedings.
The bench comprising Acting Chief Justice P. Sam Koshy and Justice Narsing Rao Nandikonda was hearing a writ appeal filed by the National Institute for the Empowerment of Persons with Intellectual Disabilities (Divyangjan) and others. The single judge allowed a writ petition filed by C. Siddeshwar, an Assistant Administrative Officer of the institute, set aside the order of compulsory retirement and directed payment of full salary from that date.
Counsel P.V. Krishnaiah, appearing for the writ petitioner, contended that the order, though described as being in public interest, was punitive in substance and was issued while disciplinary proceedings against him remained inconclusive and under interim suspension granted by the High Court. Additional Solicitor General B. Narsimha Sharma, appearing for the appellants, argued that compulsory retirement under FR 56(j) was not a punishment and required no detailed reasons.
He submitted that a Review Committee examined the service records of 27 employees and recommended the retirement of the petitioner alone, citing financial irregularities and doubtful integrity. It was further argued that the petitioner remained under suspension and could not claim full salary. The bench observed that the pendency of disciplinary proceedings did not by itself render an order of compulsory retirement punitive, but the allegations relied upon by the institute substantially overlapped with charges that remained pending for several years.
The bench noted that between 1991 and 2009 the petitioner received favourable assessments, with his integrity recorded as beyond doubt. Holding that the absence of a requirement to record reasons did not dispense with the need for the decision to genuinely serve public interest, the bench dismissed the writ appeal. It directed that the monetary benefits be worked out after giving credit for amounts already paid.